Look.
I know you don't like the woman. I understand that her pronunciation of nuclear bothers you, and makes you think of Bush.
But give it a rest.
Saying "nucular" rather than "nuclear" doesn't mean you're an idiot. It doesn't inevitably mean that you're trying to be folksy (or as some have put it, "fauxksy").
I say "nucular." My father says "nucular" - hell, when he's under stress, or spends time with his relatives, he'll even say "Warshington." I also drop final "g"s, say "kinda" and "gonna" and "you know" and "like."
It requires effort and concentration for me to pronounce words in a way that people have decided is the way that intelligent people speak.
I have a Master's degree, and a Ph.D. So does my father.
We are not stupid.
We understand that the way we both grew up speaking is considered the intonation of hicks and imbeciles. We both, as a result, try to speak "better" especially when we are in public.
But you know what? How you pronounce a word says nothing about your character, your intelligence, your values, or your education.
All it says is whether you are (a) one of the lucky people who grew up speaking "the right way" as your native accent, (b) one of the people who did not, or (c) one of the people who did not and makes a conscious effort to abandon the speech patterns of their childhood to fit in with the expectations of others.
I get that people have linguistic pet peeves. I hate the misuse of apostrophes, and of their/there/they're, and I dislike the use of words like "utilize" and "impact."
But that's because there are established linguistic rules of grammar that are required for educated writing.
English has established rules of spelling - essential in a language where the pronunciation of words is all over the place. I'm never going to spell "nuclear" "nucular" unless I'm making a point about the word's phonetics. My father and I both know that the word "Washington" doesn't have an "R" in it, and that the word for a small stream is not spelled like the word for a pain in the neck.
But that's spelling.
Again, it requires effort and conscious attention - repeated every time these words come up in conversation - for us to sound like intelligent people.
Because so many of you are so prejudiced against regional and working-class accents that you assume that anyone who has them must be an ignorant hick.
Now, Palin's doing this in reverse - she's using her accent to distance herself from her upper-middle-class lifestyle, her position of power, and her lofty ambitions.
And you know what? For some people, it may work. Because for years we have all been told that a person with imperfect language must be stupid, just as a person from a small town must be a clueless rube, and you know what? It gets old.
I don't want to sympathize with Palin. She is selfish, power-hungry, and opposed to everything I value. But some days, like now, it's pretty hard not to.
Recent Comments